What is the difference between harry potter and the chronicles of narnia

Essay Sample Check Writing Quality. The movies, Narnia and Harry Potter target both children and adults. Children are targeted as the child protagonist in both movies uses imagination to fantasise about magical worlds and can do magical things.

Adults are targeted in both movies as the directors; Andrew Adamson, Narnia, and Chris Columbus, Harry Potter, wanted the movies to provoke the use of imagination in adults and the meaning behind the stories. The similar qualities of Narnia and …show more content… Both movies explore the idea that magic is real and the magical world is completely different to the real world.

The idea of the cupboard is to create a place that can be used to escape reality. Whist they both have guardians that defend the children as they are on their journey, the movies are still entirely dependent on the children to protect …show more content… Narnia and Harry Potter are told from the child protagonists perspective.

Due to children having the imagination to create a magical world because they are not blinded by the evils of reality. The ideas and themes of each movie is similar in the way of it being a world that only children can see and this world having completely different aspects to the real world.

Also, the idea of both movies is the children must save the adults from the evil characters. Lastly, characterisation is used in both movies but in different ways. The use of the evil character in Narnia creates a confusion for children as the evil is represented by things that is usually associated with good people.

Whilst in Harry Potter the evil is directly implied with its use of language, tone and behaviour whilst speaking about him and how scared they are of him. Get Access. Better Essays. The Importance Of Fairy Tales? Read More. Good Essays. Harry Potter Influence Words 2 Pages. Harry Potter Influence. Satisfactory Essays. Alice In Wonderland Essay. The difficulty is actually threefold:. The difficulty with the magical elements in the Harry Potter books is that the magic is being portrayed as being a skill that can be learned by children in our world, if they possess the predisposition for it Yes, I know this statement is vastly simplified.

In the Chronicles, the children almost never practice magic themselves, and once when Lucy tries to, in Voyage of the Dawn Treader, she ends up probably destroying one of her friendships.

The final confrontation is a bit eerie, but nothing too horribly violent, though we do have an instance of a human being possessed by a malevolent spirit but that fits more into category 1. By Book Two, Chamber of Secrets, we have a young girl also possessed killing chickens not to eat , and quite a bloody confrontation in the climactic scene. Skip on to Book Four, Goblet of Fire, and any semblance of these being child-appropriate books seems to be lost.

At the time of this article, Book Seven has yet to be released. Is there violence in the Narnia books? Yes, but you will notice it is tempered. Possibly the most terrifying scene in the series is the sacrifice of Aslan, but you will note that the girls look away at the moment the witch actually kills him.

Quite apart from magic or violence in either story, is the morality that is being taught in either series. Lewis was especially preachy. Reading them now I find that his subliminal message isn't very subliminal at all. Really, C. Lewis had very different objectives to mine.

When I write, I don't intend to make a point or teach philosophy of life. A problem you run into with a series is how the characters grow up The characters in Enid Blyton's Famous Five books act in a prepubescent way right through the series. In the Narnia books the children are never allowed to grow up, even though they are growing older. There are many in and out of universe things to, so to speak, prove this, but I'll only list a few. To start with if anything was going to be in the other's universe Harry Potter would be in Narnia 's as The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe was originally published in and Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone was originally published in I'm not sure how a book series having the same amount of books in any way dictates that the works are in the same universe.

In Harry Potter sure and even then not really but in Narnia I don't think you can call them Muggles at all. Moreover, Narnia universe was created something like 50 years prior to Harry Potter universe, so technically it would be other way round but it's not really the case.

There is also different underlying references throughout the series: while Harry Potter's arc with Voldemort and Death Eaters has a lot in common with Hitler and Nazi's view of the world, Narnia has more of a Christian theme. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more.

Are the Narnia books and Harry Potter set in the same fictional universe? Ask Question. Asked 2 years, 9 months ago. Active 2 years, 8 months ago. Viewed 2k times. I've noticed many similarities for example: the lion symbol on the suits of armor looks exactly the same as Harry Potter's Gryffindor lion there are 7 books in the Narnia and Harry Potter septuplegies the main characters are part Muggle or full Muggles I'm sure there is more I haven't listed, But, is Narnia the same fictional universe as Harry Potter or a different universe entirely?

Improve this question. Helga Potter Helga Potter 1 1 1 bronze badge. Either they're in the same universe or they aren't. The question is DVable at will for a couple of reasons, but is not opinion-based.